Welcome to the Industrial Automation website!

NameDescriptionContent
XING-Automation
E-mail  
Password  
  
Forgot password?
  Register
当前位置:

Why is Germany phasing out nuclear power? Why end nuclear power now?

F: | Au:佚名 | DA:2024-01-03 | 635 Br: | 🔊 点击朗读正文 ❚❚ ▶ | Share:

The first Renewable Energy Act, which provided for on-grid subsidies to wind and solar producers, contributed to a boom in renewables, sharply lowering the price of new technologies and growing the share of renewables in Germany's electricity consumption from 6 percent in 2000 to 46 percent in 2020. This shift in electricity supply - known as the "energy transition" - has raised awareness and ambition for the decarbonisation of other sectors, and led to the 2020 decision to phase out coal power by 2038 at the latest. Germany's new government wants to bring that end date forward to 2030.

04. Why doesn't Germany phase out coal before nuclear?

Germany has often been criticised for phasing out low-carbon nuclear power, while the proportion of CO2-heavy coal in its energy mix remains relatively high. There are several reasons and explanations for this.

The decision to phase out nuclear power is also the starting point for decarbonizing the country's electricity supply, mainstreaming renewables and lowering their prices until they are cheaper than new conventional power plants. While most countries made their decision to quit coal after the 2015 Paris Agreement (and several others committed to ending coal use at the UN climate summit COP26 in 2021), the early 2000s or 2010s were a very early period for Germany to stop using historically familiar, domestically produced and reliable sources of energy. Renewable energy sources were not yet available to provide such affordable and secure energy.

Since the decision to phase out nuclear power in 2000, the share of coal in Germany's electricity generation has fallen from 43 percent in 2011 (when seven nuclear power plants were closed) to 23.4 percent in 2020. No new coal plants have been planned/built since 2007.

However, if a country that considers itself a pioneer of climate action still has some of the largest emissions from power stations in Europe, that does paint a pretty dubious picture. However, Stefan Rahmstorf, head of Earth system analysis at the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research, noted: "Emissions from the energy sector have been cut in half since 1990 [...] It is other sectors that have so far failed to meet their targets."

The campaign against fossil power plants led Germany to agree in 2020 to phase out coal power generation by 2038. Following the country's decision to bring forward its net zero target date to 2045, the new government has said it plans to bring forward the coal exit "ideally" to 2030.

Simon Energiewende, Germany director of Agora Energiewende, a German think tank. "The rate of reduction in Germany is too slow to be simply linked to the timing of the phase-out of nuclear and coal," Muller told Clean Energy Network. "After a few years of boom, the government let the renewable energy market collapse. With the more ambitious expansion of renewables, the share of CO2-free power generation is now likely to be even higher, "he said.

Another difference between coal and nuclear power is that, despite being enthusiastically embraced by the major political parties in the 1960s, nuclear power was a relatively new phenomenon that did not have a solid base in society and was quickly discredited by accidents and protests. Coal mining, on the other hand, has been entrenched in several German states for 200 years. It used to have a large (and often proud) workforce, wield considerable political influence, and was often a major employer and economic stronghold of a region. It is (or, in the case of hard coal, was) a domestically available energy source.

These are among the reasons why it will be easier for Germany to initiate a withdrawal from nuclear power before phasing out coal.

05. Will Germany emit more CO2 as a result of phasing out nuclear power?

Some climate activists, researchers and pro-nuclear groups argue that Germany could have prevented carbon dioxide emissions if it had decided to reduce coal electricity consumption before it stopped using nuclear power. "From a pure emissions perspective, it has always been a questionable idea to shut down German nuclear power plants before the end of their life," Hans Koenig, project leader commissioned by Aurora Energy Research, told Bloomberg.

The Federal Environment Agency uses the following emissions estimates: onshore wind at 10 g CO2e/KWH, solar PV at 67 g CO2e/KWH, nuclear at 68 g CO2e/KWH, natural gas at 430 g CO2e/KWH and lignite at more than 1 kg CO2e/KWH.

Pro-nuclear activists Rainer Moormann, a former physical chemist at the Julich Research Center, and Anna Veronica Vunderland of the Held Institute for the History of Eastern Central Europe in Marburg proposed in 2020 to keep the last six plants operating, Would enable Germany to close all its lignite plants in North Rhine-Westphalia - by reversing the decision to shut down the last six reactors in 2021 and 2022 and keep them running until the end of the decade, Germany's total CO2 emissions could be reduced by 10 percent.

Economists at the German Institute for Economic Research (DIW) concluded in a recent paper that "the reduction in nuclear energy will temporarily lead to an increase in the use and import of fossil energy sources, which will increase CO2 emissions in the short term." However, as renewable energy accelerates, these emissions should decrease rapidly." In the short term, nuclear power will indeed be replaced by fossil fuel power plants and imports. According to the DIW, a 15 terawatt hour (TWh) increase in imports would increase emissions by about 40 million tonnes of CO2. Other studies have shown that, in the context of the overall cap of the European Emissions Trading System (EU ETS), the rise in German emissions would be compensated for by the fall in emissions from other countries, keeping overall emissions stable while seeing a small increase in the price of CO2 allowances.

  • Mannesmann Rexroth VT3006-36 Analog Amplifier Card
  • Bosch Rexroth R900086160 PGF1 Gear Pump
  • Bosch Rexroth R911173263 VDP15.3 Touch Display
  • Bosch Rexroth PPC-R22.1 RJ522 Industrial Controller
  • Bosch Rexroth MSK060C-0300-NN-S1-UG0-NNNN Servo Motor
  • Bosch Rexroth R911325068 NYS04.1 Controller
  • Bosch Rexroth R911335439 CSH01.1C Control Unit
  • Bosch Rexroth R917010287 BODAS RC10 Controller
  • Bosch Rexroth R911329791 CSH01.1C Drive Controller
  • Bosch Rexroth R182432310 Runner Block Guide
  • Bosch Rexroth VT-VSPA2-1-11 Amplifier Card R900021909
  • Bosch Rexroth MKD090B-047-KG1-KN Servo Motor
  • Bosch Rexroth LTU350 Servo Amplifier 0608750108
  • Bosch Rexroth 5610102050 Pneumatic Vacuum Regulator
  • Bosch Rexroth VT5041-23/3-OV PLC Control Board
  • Bosch Rexroth VT3015 S10/E Servo Amplifier Board
  • Bosch Rexroth MSK070D-0300-NN-M2-UG1 Servo Motor
  • Bosch Rexroth 3DREP6C-21 Valve R900955887
  • Bosch Rexroth R151244013 Ball Screw Bearing Unit
  • Bosch Rexroth MSM031C-0300 Servomotor R911325140
  • Bosch Rexroth EMD-B16.1-DC024N Box R911291681
  • Bosch Rexroth MKD071B-061-GP0-KN Servo Motor
  • Bosch Rexroth MSK030C-0900-NN-M1-UG1 Servo Motor
  • Bosch Rexroth EcoDrive DKC01.3-004-3-MGP-01 Servo Controller (299772)
  • Bosch Rexroth DKC02.3-040-7 EcoDrive Controller
  • Bosch Rexroth CLC-D02.3 CLC Motion Control Board
  • Bosch Rexroth HDS05.2-W300N Drive R911190019
  • Bosch Rexroth DKCXX.3-100-7 Servo Drive Unit
  • Bosch Rexroth CSE02.1A-S3-EC Control Unit R911339030
  • Bosch Rexroth MSK040C-0600-NN-S1-UP0 Servo Motor
  • Bosch Rexroth VT3013 S36 R5 Circuit Board Card
  • Bosch Rexroth VT3000-36A Amplifier Card R90020298
  • Bosch Rexroth VPB40.3 IndraControl Module R911374113
  • Bosch Rexroth HCS02.1E-W0054-A-03-NNNN Converter with R911332574 Control Unit
  • Bosch Rexroth MHD071B-061-PG1-UN Servo Motor
  • Bosch Rexroth A2F5/60W-B3-S Piston Motor R909418904
  • Bosch Rexroth HCS01.1E-W0018-A-03-B-ET-EC-NN-NN-NN-FW IndraDrive Cs Converter
  • Bosch Rexroth 4WRPEH 6 C4B40P-2X/G24K0/A1M Proportional Directional Valve (0 811 404 647)
  • Bosch Rexroth R911405975 ctrlX OS PLC Controller
  • Bosch Rexroth CSB02.1B-ET-EC-NN-S4-NN-NN-FW Servo Control Card R911338543
  • Rexroth MSK050B-0300-NN-M1-UG0-NNN Servo Motor
  • Rexroth IndraControl VEPXX.5-ATOM Set R911374889 Panel
  • Rexroth 1070089906-GC1 1070089907-201 Board
  • Rexroth CSB01.1C-SE-ENS-EN2-NN-S-NN-FW Control Unit
  • Rexroth MKD071B-024-KG3-KN Servo Motor
  • Rexroth Indramat DKC02.3-040-7-FW Controller
  • Rexroth HCS02.1E-W0028-A-03-NNNN Servo Module
  • Rexroth HMD01.1N-W0036-A-07-NNNN Drive Module
  • Rexroth MSK050C-0600-NN-M1-UG0-NNN Servo Motor
  • Rexroth DKC02.3-040-7-FW Servo Controller
  • Bosch Rexroth VT-5014S30-R1 Amplifier Card
  • Bosch Rexroth MSK040C-0600-NN-M1-UG1 Servo Motor
  • Bosch Rexroth MKD071B-061-GG0-KN Servo Motor
  • Bosch Rexroth VT5012-S45-R1 Amplifier Card
  • Bosch Rexroth SHL03.1-NNN-S-NNN Encoder Module
  • Bosch Rexroth EFC3600-0K75 Frequency Converter
  • Bosch Rexroth VFC3610-1K50-3P4-MNA-7P-NNNNN-NNNN 1.5kW Frequency Inverter
  • Bosch Rexroth EFC5610-2K20-3P4-MDA-7P-NNNNN-L1NN 2.2kW Frequency Converter
  • Bosch Rexroth XM21 XM2100.01 PLC Control Unit
  • Rexroth CSH01.1C-ET-ENS R911328178 HMS01.1N-W0020 Drive Package
  • April AXI0010 - Single Axis Servo Controller
  • Rexroth DKC10.3-004-3-MGP-01VRS Servo Drive
  • Bosch DKC02.3-040-7-FW Servo Drive
  • Rexroth DKC06.3-040-7-FW Servo Drive Controller
  • Rexroth VPB40.3 SE T R911374113 Control Module
  • Rexroth S20-SSI-AO-1/1 R911172544-AB1 Module
  • Rexroth R911173004 AC1 GH1 PLC Control Set
  • Rexroth VPB40.3D1L-1G0NN-D1D-DN-NN-FW Module
  • Rexroth MDD071B-N-040-N2T-095GB1 Servo Motor
  • Bosch Rexroth DM15K1101-D Servo Drive Module
  • Rexroth CSH01.3C-PB-ENS-MA1-CCD-S2-S-NN-FW Drive
  • Rexroth HMS01.1N-W0036 CSB02.1B Drive Package
  • Rexroth MSK070E-0300-NN-M2-UG0-RNN Servo Motor
  • Rexroth AZPF-1X-004RCB20KB Gear Pump
  • Rexroth NFD03.1-480-055 Powerline Filter
  • Rexroth VT-VARAP1-537-20/V0 Valve Amplifier
  • Rexroth HVE04.2-W075N Supply Module
  • Rexroth HMD01.1N-W0020-A-07-NNNN Drive Controller
  • Rexroth VDP40.3DIN-D1-NN-CG HMI Computer
  • Rexroth HDS05.2-W300N-HS12-01FW Drive Module
  • Rexroth HMS01.1N-W0070-A-07-NNNN Power Section
  • Rexroth Indramat MKD071B-061-GP0-KN Servo Motor
  • Rexroth HDS03.2-W075N-HS12-01-FW Control Unit
  • Rexroth HCS02.1E-W0054-A-03-NNNN Servo Drive
  • Rexroth CML40.2-SP-330-NA-NNNN-NW IndraControl
  • Rexroth CSH01.1C-PB-ENS-NNN-MA1-S2-S-NN-FW Drive
  • Rexroth PPC-R22.1 DAQ03 Servo Drive
  • Rexroth HCS02.1E-W0070-A-03-NNNN Servo Drive
  • Rexroth RF-FLS PB M12 DIO 8/8 M12 Module
  • Rexroth Indramat TBM 1.2-40-W1-024 Servo Bleeder
  • Rexroth Indramat MKD071B-061-KG1-KN Servo Motor
  • Rexroth CML40.2-SP-330-NA-NNNN-NW IndraControl L40
  • Rexroth VCP08.2DTN-003-NN-NN-PW Operator Panel
  • Bosch Rexroth DM30K1101-D Servo Drive 670V DC
  • Rexroth PPC-R22.1N-N-Q1-NN-NN-FW Motion Controller
  • Rexroth MSK040C-0600-NN-M1-UG1-NNNN Servo Motor
  • Rexroth CSH01.1C-S3-ENS-NNN-NNN-S2-S-NN-FW Drive Controller
  • Rexroth PPC-R22.1 Motion Control Module 004566384
  • Rexroth CSH01.1C-PB-ENS-NNN-MA1-S2-S-NN-FW Controller
  • Rexroth CML25.1-3N-400-NN-NNC1-NW IndraControl L25
  • Rexroth MSK030C-0900-NN-M1-UP1-NSNN Servo Motor
  • Rexroth HCS02.1E-W0028-A-03 CSH01.1C-PB Drive Package
  • Bosch Rexroth VT-VARAP 1-537-20/V0 Amplifier
  • Bosch Rexroth PPC-R02.2N R911285402 Control Unit
  • National Instruments PCI-7342 Motion Controller
  • National Instruments PXIe-6535 Digital I/O Module
  • National Instruments PCIe-6738 Analog Output Card
  • National Instruments NI-6583 Digital I/O Adapter Module
  • National Instruments NI TB-9214 Terminal Block
  • National Instruments NI 9222 Simultaneous Analog Input Module
  • National Instruments PXIe-8364 MXI-Express Module
  • National Instruments PXI-8185 Embedded Controller
  • National Instruments PCI-1405 Device
  • National Instruments SCXI-1160 Module
  • National Instruments PCI-MIO-16E-1 Device
  • National Instruments USB-6216 Device
  • National Instruments PXIe-2543 Module
  • National Instruments PCI-5102 Digitizer
  • National Instruments PXI-6284 DAQ Device
  • National Instruments PXI-7330 Controller
  • National Instruments cFP-2100 Controller
  • National Instruments USB-6002 DAQ Device
  • National Instruments PCIe-6374 Multifunction DAQ Card
  • National Instruments PXIe-4610 Power Amplifier Module
  • National Instruments PXIe-4154 Battery Simulator
  • National Instruments PXIe-7858R Reconfigurable I/O Module
  • National Instruments BNC-2090A BNC Terminal Block
  • National Instruments cRIO-9066 CompactRIO Controller